ThoroughWiz

Racing Greats · 1968 · Timeform 141

Mill Reef: The Summer of 1971

Derby, Eclipse, King George and Arc in one season — a haul no contemporary matched.

Mill Reef's three-year-old season is the template for the complete middle-distance campaign. Beaten by Brigadier Gerard in the 2000 Guineas — the only time they met — he was never beaten again: the Derby, the Eclipse, the King George VI and Queen Elizabeth Stakes by six lengths, and the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe by three, in record time.

He was small, American-bred, owned by Paul Mellon and trained by Ian Balding, and he raced with a consistency the ratings remember: Timeform gave him 141, and the only horses above him on the all-time list are the milers he dueled with and the two immortals, Sea Bird and Frankel.

As a four-year-old he won the Prix Ganay and the Coronation Cup, and the rematch with Brigadier Gerard over a mile and a quarter was the race the sport wanted most. It never happened. Mill Reef broke a leg on the gallops in 1972; he was saved for stud, and the argument about which of the two was better has now been running, unresolved, for more than fifty years.

Sources: Racing Post, A Century of Racing, via The Free Library; IrishRacing.com; Timeform's all-time highest-rated flat horses, as published (the list on our Power Ratings page).

All champion stories · Previous: Windy City: A Two-Year-Old Rated 142 · Next: Shergar: Ten Lengths at Epsom