ThoroughWiz

Champions Who Lost · The Champions Who Lost

American Pharoah at the Graveyard of Favorites

Thirty-seven years of waiting ended at Belmont — and Saratoga collected its toll two months later.

In June 2015, American Pharoah ended the longest drought in the sport's history, becoming the first Triple Crown winner in 37 years. Two months later, on August 29, he ran in the Travers Stakes at Saratoga — the track they call the Graveyard of Favorites — and Keen Ice, a 16-1 shot, beat him by three-quarters of a length.

It was the last defeat of his life. Pharoah closed his career by winning the Breeders' Cup Classic, the first horse to complete the Grand Slam of the Triple Crown plus the Classic. The Travers loss is the useful reminder inside the fairy tale: the same summer that produced a once-in-a-generation champion also produced an ordinary Saturday at Saratoga where he was simply second best.

Sources: TASK BG verified entries, 2026-11-21 (National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame, Britannica, BloodHorse, Daily Racing Form).

All champion stories · Previous: California Chrome: The People's Horse Falls Short · Next: The 1972 Dolphins: Perfect, and Still Alone