The 1968 Colts: The Guarantee
13-1 NFL champions and 18-point favorites — beaten 16-7 in the game that made the AFL real.
The 1968 Baltimore Colts were, by the standards of their league, close to perfect: NFL champions at 13-1, favored by eighteen points in Super Bowl III against the New York Jets of the upstart AFL. Three days before the game, the Jets' quarterback, Joe Namath, guaranteed a victory. Nobody with a memory of the first two Super Bowls — both Green Bay routs — took it entirely seriously.
The Jets won 16-7. The defeat is remembered as the moment the AFL became legitimate and the merger of the two leagues became a marriage of equals. Baltimore's season did not shrink because of one afternoon; it was reframed by it. The Colts are the first entry in this collection's sports wing for a reason: sometimes the champion who loses is the one who changes the sport.
Sources: TASK BG verified entries, 2026-11-21 (official team histories, NCAA.com, Sports Illustrated, tournament records).
All champion stories · Previous: The 2011-12 Wildcats: Anthony Davis and 38-2 · Next: The 1998 Vikings: The Kick That Missed